The following is an edited confession from an anonymous source who has worked as a data consultant and editorial contributor to two widely-cited BookTok industry power lists, including one published by a major trade outlet. Their identity is known to BookTok Times editors. All details that could identify them have been removed or altered at their request. This account has not been verified independently but is consistent with information from three additional industry sources.
I want to be clear about something before I say any of this: I think the people on these lists are largely talented, largely legitimate, and largely deserving of recognition. That’s not the issue. The issue is that the methodology producing these rankings is, in the most generous framing, aspirational. And in the least generous framing, it’s a sales document dressed up as journalism.
So what does a BookTok power list actually measure?
Officially? Influence. Reach. Cultural impact. Sales lift. You’ll see these words in every editor’s note. What it actually measures is a combination of follower count, whether the creator’s publicist returned our emails, how recently the creator’s name appeared in a Variety or Publishers Weekly story, and — I cannot stress this enough — how much pressure the outlet received from publishers to include certain accounts that were launching campaigns.
The last time I contributed to a ranking exercise, we had a tiered weighting system that was supposed to feel rigorous. TikTok follower count was weighted at 30%. Estimated sales lift per post — a number that, by the way, nobody can actually verify at the scale we were pretending — was weighted at 25%. “Cultural moment” score was weighted at 20%. The remaining 25% was called “editorial judgment,” which is a polite way of saying: whoever is loudest in the room that week.
“The ‘editorial judgment’ bucket is where the list gets negotiated. It’s where a creator with 800K followers ends up above someone with 2.4M because a senior editor had dinner with the smaller creator’s publicist in March.”
I watched it happen in real time. One name — I’m not going to say who, but you’d recognize the account immediately — was pulled from the top fifteen and dropped to the high twenties because the publisher attached to their biggest recent campaign pulled a print ad buy. Nobody said that out loud. But everyone in the room knew why the ranking moved.
Which publishers are most aggressive about influencing the list?
The ones you’d expect. Macmillan’s Wednesday Books team has been running what I’d describe as a full-court press on every list that matters since early 2025. Their director of digital marketing, who I won’t name, is extraordinary at what they do — they understand that getting a creator in the top twenty of a credible power list is worth somewhere between three and five earned-media cycles that they’d otherwise have to pay for. That’s real value. I don’t blame them for playing the game.
Berkley has gotten more sophisticated about it too. Since their BookTok acquisition of the Lux imprint’s romance back catalog started converting, they’ve been seeding relationships with the consultants and editors who touch these lists months before publication. They’re not offering money — it’s subtler than that. It’s early ARCs, first access to cover reveals, invitations to events where creators and list-makers are in the same room together. The social capital accumulates.
Orbit UK is doing something smarter than anyone else right now: they’re investing in the mid-tier. Rather than fighting over placement for their biggest names, they’re quietly building relationships with creators in the 400K-to-900K follower range who are about to explode — accounts like @talesandthorns and @midnightshelfco — because those creators are easier to influence before they have their own managers telling them to protect their editorial independence.
“The lists don’t measure who is powerful. They manufacture power. There’s a difference. If you appear in the top ten for two consecutive quarters, the industry starts treating you like a top-ten creator regardless of what your actual engagement data says.”
What does the actual engagement data say that the lists won’t?
Save-to-share ratios. That’s the number I actually care about, and it’s almost never discussed in these ranking exercises because it’s harder to screenshot and harder to game. Follower counts can be purchased. View counts can be gamed with duets and stitches timed to trend cycles. But the ratio of saves to shares on a book-recommendation video tells you something real about whether the audience trusts the creator enough to bookmark the recommendation for later purchase consideration versus just passing it along for social currency.
The accounts consistently posting save-to-share ratios above 0.7 — meaning more people are saving than sharing — are almost never in the top ten of any published power list. They’re mid-follower-count creators with hyper-loyal genre-specific audiences. A fantasy account I track with 310K followers regularly moves more verified Amazon purchase data per post than several creators sitting in the top five of the most-cited list in our industry. I know this because I’ve seen the affiliate link conversion reports from two publishers who run independent attribution tracking.
- Follower count is the metric that gets measured because it’s visible. It is also the metric most divorced from actual commercial impact.
- Comment velocity in the first 90 minutes post-publication is a better signal and is almost never part of any published methodology.
- Save rate by genre is the single most predictive metric for sustained sales lift, and it requires publisher partnership data to access — which means it only flows to consultants with existing relationships, which means the lists are always going to be skewed toward creators whose publishers talk to the list-makers.
- Rewatch rate for videos over 90 seconds is increasingly the stat that major digital marketing teams at PRH and S&S are citing internally, but it hasn’t penetrated the list-making conversation yet.
Are any of the named agents and publicists on these lists actually influential in the ways the lists claim?
Some of them are genuinely powerful and the recognition is warranted. Joanna Volpe at New Leaf Literary has built something real — her ability to read which manuscripts will perform on BookTok before they’re acquired is documented in the acquisition outcomes, not just the press releases. That’s legitimate influence. Dani Segelbaum at MacKenzie Wolf has been identifying creator relationships that convert before other agents understand why the conversion is happening. Those are real skills reflected in real outcomes.
But there’s a category of agent and publicist appearing on these lists specifically because they are excellent at getting themselves onto these lists. They’re at every industry event. They respond to journalist queries within the hour. They have strong opinions delivered in quotable sentences. That’s not the same thing as being the person who actually moved the needle on a book’s commercial performance. The publicist who engineered the A Court of Thorns and Roses relaunch campaign in 2024 — quietly, without a single industry panel appearance — is not on any list I’ve ever seen. The publicists who speak at every BookTok summit absolutely are.
“There’s a publicist I know who has moved eight figures in book sales through creator campaigns in the past eighteen months. She has never appeared on a power list. She actively avoids them. She told me once that the moment you’re known as a power player, the creators you need start charging you power-player rates.”
What would an honest list actually look like?
It would be messier and less satisfying and probably less compelling to read, which is why it will never get published. An honest list would include:
- Creators ranked by verified affiliate conversion rate per 1,000 followers, with the publisher data to support it
- Agents ranked by the ratio of BookTok-originated acquisitions to total acquisitions, not by general prestige or deal size
- Publicists ranked by first-week velocity on campaigns they ran, with the sales data attached — not by reputation or event presence
- A “dark matter” category for the mid-follower creators whose actual sales lift outperforms every creator above them on the follower-count ladder
- A disclosure section identifying which publishers, agencies, or imprints had commercial relationships with the outlet publishing the list
That last one is the one nobody will touch. The advertising relationships between trade publications and the publishers whose talent appears on their lists is the open secret that makes everything else possible. I’m not alleging corruption in any legal sense. I’m saying that the structural incentives guarantee a specific kind of distortion, and the industry has decided collectively to not discuss it, because the lists are useful to too many people for too many different reasons.
Why are you saying this now?
Because the stakes are getting too high to keep pretending. When a placement in the top twenty of a power list can move a creator’s sponsored post rate from $8,000 to $35,000 — which is a real range I’ve seen in contracts crossing through people I know — then the list is no longer a fun industry conversation. It’s a financial instrument. And financial instruments that are being constructed the way I’ve described should probably come with more transparency than a masthead and a methodology paragraph that nobody reads.
I also think the creators themselves deserve better. The accounts doing genuinely extraordinary work — building real reader communities, converting browsers at rates that would make a performance marketer weep — are being evaluated by criteria that were designed to make the list legible to people who don’t understand BookTok, not to accurately describe who matters inside it.
The list that’s coming out next month — I know the outlet, I know several of the contributors — is going to be cited in acquisition conversations at four major publishers within two weeks of publication. Editors will reference it in pitch meetings. It will affect what gets bought, what gets funded, and who gets hired. That’s a lot of weight to put on a document that started as a spreadsheet where someone’s follower count got entered wrong and nobody caught it before publication.
I’m not burning the industry down. I’m asking it to look in the mirror before it dresses for the next awards dinner.